top of page
Zack Woo

What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters?

What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 1

Between instant water heaters and storage water heaters, the difference is that instant water heaters provide hot water on demand without the need for a tank, while storage water heaters store and heat a significant volume of water in a tank for later use.


In terms of energy sources, both types can operate as gas water heaters, although the gas heater efficiency might differ. Instant water heaters, often called tankless, might run on gas, providing a continuous supply of hot water, but they require a high upfront investment.


In contrast, storage water heaters generally have lower initial costs but can have higher operational expenses due to the constant re-heating of water in the tank.


This comparison highlights the trade-offs between initial installation costs and ongoing energy consumption in the choice between gas and electric water heaters.


What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 2

Instant heater vs storage heater HDB: What is the difference?

The difference between an instant heater vs storage heater HDB is that an instant heater heats water on demand and typically requires less space in the bathroom, making it a convenient choice for smaller homes in Singapore.


Instant water heaters, often referred to as electric heaters, are powered by electricity and provide hot water almost immediately without the need to store it.


On the other hand, a storage water heater, also known as an electric storage heater, stores hot water in a tank, which can be more accommodating for larger households and families who require a consistent supply of hot water.


Gas water heaters are another option, although less common in HDB settings due to space and installation requirements.


Users must consider the run costs associated with both types of heaters, with gas heaters potentially offering a cost-saving option depending on the location and availability of gas.


Understanding these differences is crucial when deciding which system might suit an upgrade in a family home, balancing factors like energy source—gas or electricity—and bathroom space.


What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 3

What is the price and cost difference between an instant heater and storage heater?

Between an instant heater and storage heater, the price and cost difference is primarily influenced by the initial purchase cost and the running costs over time.


Gas heaters, such as the gas water heater and gas instant heater, are generally more economical in terms of operational costs, especially for large households or frequent showers.


In Singapore, the installation of a typical gas water heater tank can cost around S$400 to S$800, but the long-term savings can be significant due to lower energy usage.


Meanwhile, an electric storage heater typically ranges from S$200 to S$500, depending on the model and capacity, but the cost can rise with prolonged usage as it consumes more energy.


Electric storage options, like an electric storage heater, are often preferred for consistent pressure and flow, making them ideal for different bathroom setups. It's important to discover which model suits your lifestyle, the size of your bathroom, and energy preferences for optimal benefits.


Additionally, city energy providers often offer various incentives that could factor into the decision-making process when installing a new heater tank in Singapore.


What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 4

How much electricity does each heater use?: Instant Heater vs Storage Heater Electricity Consumption

Each heater uses energy differently, impacting power consumption and running costs significantly.


In a comparison between instant water heaters and storage water heaters, instant heaters generally use less electricity for a single shower as they heat water on demand, which is ideal for HDB bathrooms.


However, storage water heaters, although they use more electricity because they maintain a constant water temperature, offer better water pressure and reliability for larger households.


When considering the best instant water heater in Singapore, models that save electricity and fit well in tight spaces are popular.


While electric storage heaters are a common choice, gas heaters—such as the best gas water heater in Singapore—offer an efficient alternative due to their ability to efficiently heat large volumes of water, making them suitable for larger families.


City energy suppliers often recommend gas water heaters as a sustainable option for high hot water demand. Whether choosing electric or gas, it is essential to consider shower frequency, bathroom size, and energy costs.


What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 5

How much power does each heater use?: Instant Water Heater vs Storage Water Heater Power Consumption

The power consumption of water heaters varies based on their type and model. Each heater uses different amounts of electricity due to its operational mechanism.


Instant water heaters, often preferred in the fast-paced city life of Singapore, offer on-demand hot water without needing to wait for a tank to heat up, thus potentially saving energy during short showers.


On the other hand, electric storage water heaters heat water in advance, maintaining it at the desired temperature, which might result in higher electricity usage if not managed properly.


In terms of safety, both electric instant heaters and electric storage water heaters must be installed properly to prevent issues such as water pressure irregularities and overheating concerns.


The false ceilings often found in Singapore bathrooms might impact heat retention and should be considered during installation.


For gas water heaters, there is an additional need to ensure proper ventilation to mitigate risks associated with gas use.


To compare electricity consumption: suppose an instant water heater uses 3kW and runs for 10 minutes per shower. In Singapore, where the average cost of electricity is about S$0.30 per kWh, the cost per shower would be approximately S$0.15.


Calculating for a storage water heater, which uses around 2kW and is on for 2 hours per day to ensure hot water is ready upon demand, the daily cost would be around S$1.20.


Therefore, selecting between instant and storage heaters involves comparing these operational dynamics, as well as considering factors like personal usage habits, pressure, and the needs of each bathroom.


What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 6

Which is better instant or traditional water heater?

An instant water heater is better than a traditional water heater in terms of energy efficiency and cost-effectiveness.


Unlike traditional storage models that heat large volumes of water at once and intermittently supply heat to maintain the water's temperature, tankless instant water heater only consume electricity when in use.


This makes them a more energy-efficient choice for those in Singapore, where hot water is primarily needed for showers and small bathroom tasks.


The reduction in energy usage not only decreases electricity bills but also prolongs the lifespan of electric water heaters.


When installed correctly, instant heaters provide a steady pressure of hot water, making them ideal for homes with limited space, as they don’t require room for a large tank.


Moreover, a gas instant heater can serve as an alternative to electric models, offering an efficient solution without depending heavily on electric power.


Comparing gas and electric water heaters shows that both serve well in providing hot water, but instant heaters stand out in their operational efficiency and quick response time, especially during consecutive showers.


Ultimately, the choice between an instant and a traditional water heater depends on your specific household needs and circumstances.


What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 7

Are instant water heaters good?: Instant Water Heater Singapore

Yes, instant water heaters are good because they offer energy efficiency and significant cost savings over time.


These units are designed to heat water directly as it runs through the system, eliminating the need for a slow heating process and reducing standby energy loss, which is a common issue with storage models.


When upgrading your bathroom with an instant heater, installation is a streamlined process, often completed quickly once the unit is installed, allowing you to enjoy hot water almost instantly after opening the door to your water flow.


Comparing electric heaters to gas heaters, instant models available on the Singapore market often provide consistent hot water tank pressure at a lower operational cost. Read our easy article to find out what is the difference between gas water heater vs electric water heater!


While the initial cost may seem higher, their long life and reduced energy consumption ultimately translate to financial benefits.


This makes them a smart choice for homeowners looking to save on electric bills while enjoying reliable hot showers without the hassle of dealing with a storage tank.


Whether considering a new water heater installation service setup or a retrofit upgrade, the compact and efficient nature of these units, combined with the ability to run cold water through them, solidifies their role as a preferred electric and gas heating solution.


What is the difference between instant water heaters and storage water heaters? Image 8

What is the major drawback to storage water heaters?

The major drawback to storage water heaters is their limited supply of hot water for extended use, which can be particularly frustrating for a large family or household that relies on long showers.


This limitation is compounded by the energy loss due to radiant heat from the tank, as energy standards require these large tanks to run efficiently, yet they can still consume electricity slowly over time.


In HDB spaces like those in Singapore, the issue of requiring more space becomes a significant drawback; large tanks mandated by energy standards take up precious real estate in bathrooms, impacting the final decision when comparing models for installation.


While they offer certain advantages like consistent water pressure and safety, these heaters are not always suitable for every location due to their size and reliance on either electric or gas models. Discover what are the common water heater problems in Singapore here!


The cost to install and run these units, alongside the maintenance service life, should be carefully considered. Learn what is the importance of water heater maintenance here!


Ultimately, the comparison between traditional storage heaters and their instant counterparts may reveal that, while convenient for certain setups, they are not the ideal choice for every household looking to upgrade their water heating solutions.



What is the difference between a storage tank water heater and an instantaneous water heater?

The difference between a storage tank water heater and an instantaneous (tankless) water heater is how they heat and store water.


Storage tank systems constantly heat water, which leads to higher energy costs due to ongoing heat loss as hot water is stored and maintained at a consistent temperature.


On the other hand, instantaneous water heaters experience no heat loss since water is heated on demand, providing a more energy-efficient option.


The compact size of tankless heaters makes them ideal for households with limited space, allowing for easy installation in convenient locations such as bathrooms.


As families strive to save on energy costs and discover more efficient models in the market, understanding the benefits of each type is crucial.


A tankless system may offer lifestyle advantages by reducing wait times for hot showers and conserving energy, but it's essential to compare the initial installation cost and pressure considerations to ensure suitability for your household's needs.


Whether seeking to upgrade from a traditional system or simply exploring the range of options available in Singapore, balancing cost, efficiency, and convenience will guide the best choice in heating water for your lifestyle. Contact Thong Nian Engineering for water heater installation, replacement and repair services in Singapore.



2 views

Comments


bottom of page